In the annals of Academy Awards history, few moments are as surreal, unforgettable, or widely replayed as the Best Picture mix-up at the the 2017 Oscars. La La Land was mistakenly announced as the winner — only for the error to be corrected minutes later, revealing Moonlight as the actual winner.
Amid the shock, one image stood out: Ryan Gosling, seated among the La La Land cast, visibly trying—and failing—to suppress laughter. Why did he react that way? What was going through his mind? And how has that reaction since become part of the mythology of that night?
Let’s rewind, revisit, and reflect.
Setting the Stage: Oscars 2017, La La Land, and Moonlight
The 89th Academy Awards took place on February 26, 2017, at the Dolby Theatre in Hollywood, hosted by Jimmy Kimmel. Wikipedia The year was already notable: La La Land, the modern musical with Ryan Gosling and Emma Stone, had tied the all-time record for Oscar nominations (14) and was considered a strong favorite for many major awards. Wikipedia+2Wikipedia+2 Meanwhile, Moonlight, a smaller, deeply human drama, had earned serious critical acclaim and was in strong Oscar conversations as well. Wikipedia+2Wikipedia+2
That night, La La Land won six Oscars overall, including Best Director, Best Actress, Best Original Score, Best Original Song, Best Cinematography, and Best Production Design. Wikipedia+2Wikipedia+2 But the biggest prize, Best Picture, was initially and mistakenly called as La La Land — an error that would become one of the most talked-about moments in awards show history. Wikipedia+4Pitchfork+4Wikipedia+4
When presenters Warren Beatty and Faye Dunaway opened the envelope and declared La La Land the winner, confusion rippled through the audience. But soon, as acceptance speeches began, crew members rushed the stage. It became evident that the wrong envelope had been given, and in short order, the producers of La La Land were told the real winner was Moonlight. Wikipedia+2Pitchfork+2
Jordan Horowitz, one of the La La Land producers, famously intervened mid-speech: “I’m sorry, there’s been a mistake.” He then held up the correct card that read Moonlight. Wikipedia+2Pitchfork+2 The audience, stunned, watched as Moonlight’s team hurriedly mounted the stage to accept their award. WIRED+2Wikipedia+2
The sequence of events was chaotic, emotional, and dramatic — a perfect storm of human error, high stakes, and televised spectacle. And in the eye of that storm sat Ryan Gosling, trying to process it all.
Ryan Gosling’s Reaction: Why He Laughed
Photos and video from the moment show Gosling with a mixture of disbelief and confusion. Mid-gag, he’s seen covering his mouth, trying to compose himself, while others around him seem stunned, anxious, or speechless. That reaction quickly became a viral image, sparking memes, commentary, and curiosity.
Over time, Gosling offered his own explanation for that laughter — and it wasn’t mockery or smug triumph. According to interviews, what he experienced was a swirl of panic, relief, and raw emotional release.
As he told The Guardian and others:
“I was watching people start to have this panicked reaction in the crowd… guys were coming on with headsets and I felt like someone had been hurt.” The Guardian+1
“I thought there was some kind of medical situation, and I had this worst-case scenario playing out in my head.” The Guardian+1
“And then I just heard Moonlight won and I was so relieved that I started laughing.” The Guardian+2Variety+2
In other words: in the span of seconds, he shifted from fear (something was gravely wrong) to relief (no one was hurt, and the real winner was being acknowledged). That emotional pivot triggered the laughter.
He also insisted he had no ill will toward the night’s outcome, saying:
“Truthfully, I was also so thrilled that Moonlight won. It’s such a groundbreaking film… I’m so happy for them that they were being recognized.” The Guardian+1
Even in that moment of bewilderment, Gosling’s reaction carried a level of respect, humility, and emotional authenticity.
The Layers Behind That Laugh
Gosling’s laughter resonated so powerfully in part because it felt human. In a room full of polished celebrities and high production values, here was someone visibly unraveling — uncertain, emotional, vulnerable. That contrast made the moment hauntingly real.
Let’s unpack what makes that reaction especially potent:
1. Relief Amid Uncertainty
In a high-stakes situation like the Oscars, where expectations run high and reputations are on the line, anything abnormal can feel catastrophic. For Gosling, the sudden scramble (crew rushing, presenters confused) looked like an emergency. When he realized it was a procedural mess, not a collision or medical crisis, the release was visceral.
2. Empathy for the Moment
Everyone in that room — from the La La Land team to the presenters and the Moonlight creatives — was under intense pressure. Gosling’s laugh, rather than insinuating triumph, signaled recognition of how overwhelming and absurd the moment was for everyone.
3. Acknowledgment of What Should Be
Gosling’s reaction also subtly reflects his understanding: Moonlight deserved the award. His delight for their win, expressed in interviews, suggests his laughter was not gloating but genuine emotional release — in part because things ended more fairly than they had begun. The Guardian+1
4. Vulnerability in Performance
Actors, especially ones as practiced and poised as Gosling, are adept at masking raw emotion. That night, though, the curtain briefly slipped. It reaffirmed that even celebrity images can fracture under pressure — and sometimes the authentic reaction is the one people remember the most.
How That Moment Redefined a Night
The La La Land/Moonlight mix-up was already destined for Oscar lore. But Gosling’s laugh became a visual anchor — a reminder that for all the glamour, humans were at the center of this spectacle.
That moment has been revisited in retrospectives, awards show memes, Instagram posts, and pop culture essays. It’s also often used as shorthand to show how unpredictable live TV, high emotion, and human error can collide.
That said, Gosling’s reaction didn’t overshadow the real story — Moonlight’s win, or the conversation about representation, storytelling, and recognition in Hollywood. If anything, his laughter humanizes the event, reminding us that even stars grapple with confusion, embarrassment, and release.
Why That Laugh Still Matters
Several years later, the image of Gosling suppressing laughter remains so striking because it captures so much:
- A moment of emotional truth: Rather than a rehearsed reaction, it feels spontaneous and unguarded.
- Contrast to the polished veneer: Awards shows are meticulously produced. This was a flaw — and it became the most unfiltered moment of the night.
- A reminder of what awards can’t contain: No matter how tightly scripted, events with humans in them can unravel.
- Legacy and conversation starter: The fallibility of the Oscars, the gravity of recognition, and the humanity of artists are all underscored in that laughter.
Behind the Scenes: Errors, Accountability, and Aftermath
To understand fully why the mistake happened, and how the actors and Academy handled it, it helps to revisit the circumstances.
The root cause: the presenters were handed the wrong envelope — they opened Emma Stone’s Best Actress winner card instead of the Best Picture card. The Guardian+5Pitchfork+5WIRED+5 That error triggered confusion, hesitation from Warren Beatty (who paused significantly before calling La La Land), and ultimately chaos. Wikipedia+5Wikipedia+5WIRED+5
When it became clear something was wrong, the La La Land team had already begun giving acceptance speeches. Oscar crew members and production staff rushed the stage, took the envelopes, and the error was corrected. Wikipedia+3Wikipedia+3WIRED+3 Jordan Horowitz’s assertion — “there’s been a mistake” — and his on-camera reveal of the correct card have become defining moments of the mishap. Wikipedia+2WIRED+2
PricewaterhouseCoopers (PwC), the accounting firm responsible for tallying Oscars results and handling the envelopes, issued an apology. Their partners involved — Brian Cullinan and Martha Ruiz — were barred from involvement in future Oscars ceremonies. Wikipedia+3Pitchfork+3WIRED+3
In the wake of the incident, many called for stricter protocols, redundancies in presentation, and public awareness of how small missteps can cascade into large spectacle. The Academy and production teams largely took the fall, and the night is often cited as a cautionary tale in live television production.
A Lasting Legacy: Laughs, Awards, and Memory
Years later, when people reference the “night La La Land almost won Best Picture,” often the first mental image isn’t the award card or the speeches — it’s Gosling’s smile, his hands covering his face, the tension in his composure. That laugh encapsulates disbelief, restlessness, and humanity all at once.
What we can take away:
- Spectacle and humanity intertwine. No matter the glitz, real emotions can dismantle perfect facades.
- Acknowledgment of truth matters. In a night of confusion, the right film was eventually honored — and that rescue matters.
- Sometimes authenticity is in the small moments. Big awards, big speeches — but the moments people remember often come in between.
So yes — Ryan Gosling’s laughter was more than a reaction in that instant. It became a symbol: of pressure, of the fragility of performance, and of how the best stories sometimes emerge in the unplanned breaks.
Leave a Reply